For a play named after a family dwelling, Dave Malloy’s Three Houses has surprisingly little structure. Set in a magical cocktail bar with an orchestra that can follow along in any key, three strangers share their experiences in a confessional open-mic night. When the pandemic broke out, each one of them had just gone through a break-up with a partner and found themselves secluded and struggling mentally. While there are similar strands within their tales, their ordeals only lightly touch, like their pinkies when they finally share a table. Along the way, there are some wonderfully creative moments and beautiful melodies. But like the current drive along the crumbling Highway 1 in Big Sur, a final point remains illusive.
In House #1, Susan (Margo Seibert) had been researching her next novel in Finland when COVID hit. Unable to get back to the United States, she retreats to her grandmother’s abandoned house in the Latvian woods. In a haze of red current wine, weed, and OCD, she uses the time to learn what she can about her ancestor. House #2 is set to more uptempo tunes as we move from the deep woods to the sunny desert. When her aunt returns to Korea leaving her New Mexico home unoccupied, Sadie (Mia Pak) takes refuge there. Painfully missing her girlfriend, she further retreats into a SIM she has meticulously modeled on memories of her grandparents. House #3 is actually a small basement apartment into which Beckett (J.D. Mollison) has moved after the end of his marriage. On every level, it becomes the darkest of the dwellings, especially after he learns that his grandparents have just passed away in Ireland and paranoia sets in.
Three Houses is the final piece of Malloy’s trilogy which includes Ghost Quartet and the memorable Octet. Having written the music, lyrics, book and orchestrations, this work completely embraces his usual fascination with fables. As they grapple with the effects of isolation and regret, each of our storytellers develops a relationship with a fictional being represented by puppets with tremendous personality designed by James Ortiz. Elements of The Three Little Pigs play key roles and even show up in a sweater. But when the inevitable wolf finally makes it to the door, he is dressed in grandma’s nightgown, which for fairytale purists will be perplexing.
All three soloists are terrific and support each other vocally and energetically. Henry Stram and Ching Valdes-Aran appear as all of the mystical grandparents. Scott Stangland rounds out the cast exuding something between command and menace as the bartender/MC Wolf. However, Annie Tippe’s direction is both mystifying and maddening, especially given her assured hand with Octet. The same black box space has been splendidly designed by the imaginative team of dots to feel warm and inclusive and a tad old-fashioned. Fabric is draped all along the mezzanine, and the orchestra members sit in armchairs adorned with crocheted throws. Center stage is an elaborate wooden bar, but even from the middle of the side section — normally a great spot in ¾ round — I could not make out what was on the changing backdrop behind it. The vast majority of the staging is forward facing with the actors sometimes positioned side-by-side blocking each other from view. Lighting designer Christopher Bowser has added some attention-getting effects and Haydee Zelideth costumes are a likewise literally colorful component that visually adds to the stories. Nick Kourtides envelops the audience with his sound design, which appropriately alternates between feeling comforting and smothering.
Ultimately, Three Houses is more like a trio of discontinuous chapters of an unfinished novel than a fully fleshed out musical. While the emotive songs and fanciful imagery of Octet have carried over, the clear interconnection of those characters is missing here. But there is some interesting terrain explored in finding discipline amid chaos and all the ways in which you can and can’t get to know someone else and — through them — yourself: vast themes to cover in a mere 100 minutes. The production runs through June 9 at the Signature Theatre (480 West 42nd Street) where Malloy is Premiere Resident. Tickets ($49 – $124) and information are available at https://signaturetheatre.org/show/three-houses/
The Unforgettable Line 